This low carb pot roast recipe is flavorful and delicious. Beef roast and vegetables are slow cooked in a delicious broth gravy until the meat is fall-apart tender. A comfort food classic!

Hooray for cooler weather and my favorite time of year. This month I look forward to brisk after dinner walks with my family followed by cozy evenings spent in front of the fireplace (or t.v. - let's be real). It’s time for fuzzy sweaters and curling up with a good book (or iPhone) and the resident animal foot-warmer.
Festive gatherings mark the season and provide us with a chance to shine by sharing our best recipes with family and friends. Whether it’s grandmother’s recipe for cheese pie or a great comfort food favorite like pot roast, everyone has a star recipe.
Pot roast is classic comfort food which delivers melt-in-your-mouth, fall-apart tender beef. But, let us not forget those savory cooked vegetables, in a broth so rich in body and flavor, that it will have you making excuses to sit at the table longer. And, pot roast is one of those fix-it-and-forget it meals that's super easy to prepare. Sure it takes a good 15-20 minutes to get everything ready to go, but after that, it's hands-off until it's done.
I've worked on this low carb beef pot roast recipe on and off for over a year. It’s mouthwatering delicious and fairly easy to make. I've prepared it both in the crockpot and in the oven and prefer this oven method simply because it concentrates the flavors - and I’ll take flavorful over fast and less flavorful any day. Luckily, this pot roast recipe is pretty easy and it does most of the cooking by itself.
The recipe starts with a chuck roast. I like to use chuck roast for my pot roast because the meat is marbled throughout and there is a lot of connective tissue between the muscle. If it’s cooked long enough, all of the fat and connective tissues melt out providing a beautiful “body” to the broth and leaving the meat, fork-tender. My chuck roast was 2 ¼ pounds and after cooking was enough for 6 generous portions or 8 smaller portions. Since chuck roast is a fatty cut, I like to remove any visible fat on the outside of the roast before beginning.
I DID use potatoes in the recipe and 1 medium carrot. Some will balk at this - and that’s okay. There are many ways to follow a low carb diet and I allow higher carb ingredients in very tiny amounts in my recipes if they do not add more than 1-2 net carbs per serving. You may sub according to how you follow your low carb diet. I am confident in saying this recipe is suitable for Atkins or any ketogenic or LCHF diet.
Anyway, I found the smallest waxy potatoes I could - about the size of a quarter. My 10 tiny potatoes equaled ¼ pound, yielding 1 - 1 ½ potatoes per person, which is well within carb limits in terms of a whole meal.
I did test this low carb pot roast recipe with turnips and rutabaga last year but the root vegetables tasted dirty and became waterlogged and mushy. Radishes, too, lost their texture and became mushy. Lastly, I tested celery root which tasted good, but also mushy. Tiny new potatoes were perfect.
The perfect accompaniment to this oven pot roast is mashed cauliflower mixed with aged cheddar cheese. It 's a delicious low carb meal the whole family loves.
This fantastic low carb pot roast is 6 net carbs per serving!
Low Carb Pot Roast
Ingredients
The Roast
- 2 ½ pounds chuck roast
- 1 tablespoons bacon fat or oil of your choice
- salt and pepper for seasoning
Vegetables
- ¼ pound (4 oz) very small wax potatoes (or sub turnips or radishes)
- 6 ounces pearl onions skinned, left whole
- 1 medium (5-6 oz) carrot, peeled and cut into big chunks,
- 2 large stalks celery, sliced
- 2 cloves garlic, sliced
Seasoning
- 1 teaspoon dried parsley
- 1 teaspoon dehydrated onion flakes
- ½ teaspoon granulated garlic
- ½ teaspoon dried thyme
- ½ teaspoon dried dill
- ½ teaspoon salt
- ½ teaspoon pepper
- ¼ teaspoon celery salt
For the Gravy
- 1 cup unsalted beef broth stock or bone broth
- ½ cup dry red wine
- ¼ cup (2 oz) tomato paste
- - extra water as needed if your pot has a loose fitting lid
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 300 F and place the rack to the middle position. Trim any visible fat on the outside of the roast. Measure the seasonings into a small bowl. Peel the pearl onions by first slicing off the stem end, then using the blade of a paring knife to help coax the thin skin off of the onion. It will take several minutes to skin them all.
- Heat a large dutch oven over medium heat. Dry the chuck roast with a paper towel and season both sides well with salt and pepper. When the pot is very hot, add the fat and swirl to coat the bottom of the pot. Brown the chuck roast on one side for 4-5 minutes then flip and brown the other side for another 4-5 minutes. Turn the heat to low.
- While the dutch oven is heating and the meat is browning, start preparing the vegetables, adding them to a large bowl as you go. Then, nestle the vegetables in the pot around the browned pot roast. Add the seasonings, sprinkling them evenly over all.
- In a medium bowl, add the wine to the tomato paste little by little while mixing with a small whisk or fork. Then add the beef broth. Pour the mixture over the ingredients in the dutch oven. The liquid should be almost to the top of the roast. If not, add a little more broth until it is. Turn the heat up to medium until the liquid is hot and begins to simmer.
- Cover and place the pot roast into the oven to cook for 3 hours or until the roast is fall-apart tender. It's done when a fork pierces easily all the way through the meat and/or it shreds easily with a fork. Check after 3 hours but it may take as long as 4 depending on how thickly cut the chuck roast is.
- **Check the pot every hour to add water if you have a lose fitting lid. At the end of cooking, replenish the gravy with water and scrape the caramelized bits (spatters) from the side of the pot into the gravy. Skim the fat and check the gravy or for seasoning.
- Turn off the oven and return the pot roast to the oven to keep it warm for up to two hours. Make sure to add more water if needed. If left on the stove top it will keep hot for up to an hour.
NOTE: The nutritional information listed reflects the ACTUAL ingredients and quantities listed in the recipe. It does NOT reflect carb counts using subs - that's misleading and I don't play games. This is a LOW CARB recipe. It is low enough in carbs to be considered at keto carb levels. Keto is a metabolic state (brought on by eating at or below 50 total carbs (about 20-25 net carbs)) a day, and is not a particular food. I offer appropriate subs for the carrot (0.62 oz per person) and waxed potatoes ( 0.50 oz per person) in the post. If you don't want to use the new potatoes or carrot, use one of the subs offered in the post. I think you'll agree that a traditional recipe for pot roast uses many more carrots and potatoes as well as a gravy thickener and is many more carbs per person that this recipe. This recipe is delicious, low carb, and I stand behind it.
Notes
Nutrition
Mashed Cauliflower and Celery Root (keto, low carb)
Loaded Cauliflower Mash (keto, low carb)
Alicia
I made this lat night and it was so flavorful and delicious! Unfortunately I waited until today to portion it out. How do you recommend reheating it,
Oven or stove top?
Kim Hardesty
I use the microwave but you can warm it on the stove just fine. Just add a little water or broth and make sure to stir every so often so nothing sticks to the bottom and burns. -Kim
Michele Strickland
I am not a pot roast lover at all. I made this today mostly because I am trying to use up meat in my freezer (and because we have the same rate last name lol). That being said, this was soooooo delicious. My favorite roast I've ever had. Followed to the letter except with no dill because I didn't have it. It was wonderful. Thank you! Going to definitely try more of your recipes!
Kim Hardesty
What a fantastic comment, Michele. I'm happy you enjoyed your pot roast. Thanks for taking the time to come back and comment. Have a great week. -Kim
Slammc
Delicious! Just added mushrooms to this and no wine but damn good! Thx!
Andrew Rylander
I am making this for my family tonight. Very excited, I have used several of your recipes and they have turned out great! It is so predictable this day and age to have trolls, someone always has to butt their nose in where it doesn't belong and try to be a fact-checking vigilante. If the naysayers would just read all of the info provided they would see that their knee-jerk reactions at the first mention of the villainous vegetables were completely misplaced and they just sound ridiculous. Also, xanthan gum or guar gum are great choices for sauce thickeners, just remember a little (very little) is all you need.
Andrew Rylander
** I completely forgot to ask, if one were to use a slow cooker what are the times for either low or high temp settings?
Kim Hardesty
Hi Andrew. Thank you for your defense and kind words. To cook this in the slow cooker, brown the roast in a pan and let any juices cook until dry and they turn brown (not black!). Then add the liquid ingredients to the pan and scrape up all the brown bits. Simmer the liquid in the pan until it reduces by half. Place the roast and liquid in the slow cooker and cook on high for 4-6 hours or low for 6-8. Add the vegetables at the last hour of cooking. The roast and vegetables are ready when they are fork tender. NOTE: The reason for reducing the liquid in the pan is because slow cookers "add" water while cooking, diluting the flavor of gravies and sauces. Starting with a smaller amount of concentrated liquid helps ensure that the dish will be flavorful at the end. -Kim
D Gouldin
I have found that yucca is a good substitute for potatoes. It is not low in carbs or calories, but it suits my needs as a nightshade intolerant person!
Christine
I don't blame you for standing by your recipe, it's delicious and versatile. I added potatoes for my carb'ers, and turnip for myself.
Stacey
This was so easy and packed with so much flavor. The first night I ate this I was thinking every week there would be a pot roast.
I'm sorry there is so much 'outrage' over potatoes and carrots. I will say for me it's easier not to have those in because they can start a slippery slide. Potatoes in particular. Yet, it also opened up my eyes to appreciating that some real food does not have to be off the menu completely, but limited immensely.
It is nice to be able to make this for a 'mixed' audience. I can do potatoes for others and throw in some cauliflower or radishes later.
Cannot get over the aroma this sent through my house as it was braising. DELICIOUS.
Ralph
Really liked the flavor. I eliminated the wax potatoes to lower carbs and it still turned out great!
Kaley
Wow! This was so darn delicious! I have made pot roasts for years and this is the only one I’ll make from now on. To be honest this was my first time cooking a roast in a Dutch oven. I used home made bone broth, radishes, and fresh green beans in addition to the celery, onions, garlic and carrots. I also put 1/2 tsp rosemary (love it) and the only major addition I made was to add about 2oz of cream cheese at the end and continued to cook uncovered in the oven for 30minutes. Cream cheese really is a delicious addition to a roast or stew. Makes the sauce thick and creamy. Thanks for this recipe! Wonderful!!
Dawn
Thanks for the delicious recipe! Turned out really good and was very simple to make in a dutch oven. I ended up chopping up the leftover meat on a cookie sheet and placing under the broiler to reheat. So yummy with the crispy bits and parts of the gravy caramelizing.
Sandie
Excellent recipe! I appreciate the commentary provided regarding the use of radishes and potatoes! There is more than 1 way to Keto! Thank you so much for sharing this!!
Donna Keeler
I made tonight and my husband said best pot roast I ever made, I did add mire potatoes because my husband doesn’t eat low carb. I used 2 1/2 pound roast ind was just enough to feed 4 of us.
Christi Henderson
I have now made this recipe twice and it really is just a perfect roast. The first time I used turnips and radishes and they actually came out pretty tasty (I agree they were a bit watery but still good) and the second time I used the little potatoes. Each time I made this the Hubs was very pleased and leftovers are just the bomb!! Thanks again for an awesome recipe, I really enjoy your site and I now going to find you on Instagram!
Kim
I'm so pleased you and your husband enjoy the recipe, Christi. Thanks so much for taking the time to come back and write a comment. Enjoy the rest of your week. -Kim
Stacy Scott
If I needed to skip the wine, should I double the beef broth? Thanks!
Kim
Hi Stacy, just sub the beef broth for the wine. You can add more broth if it starts to evaporate. If you are doing it in a crockpot, again, sub the beef broth for the amount of wine and boil it all down by half before adding to the crock pot since crock pots make liquid. -Kim
Richard Kohout
If your vegetables get mushy, just don't put them in the pot until the last hour of cooking.
Mel
Potatoes and Carrots are not low carb!! Please don't call this low carb.
Kim
Hi Mel. This recipe is absolutely low carb and even at ketogenic levels per serving. I explain in the post and recipe why it is and also provide subs for those who don't want to use carrots or potatoes. For that matter, onions contain high amounts of sugars and I see people using lots of onions in recipes. I keep mine at a minimum. I stand behind this delicious low carb recipe. -Kim
Mary Monk
One medium sized potato is 37 g of carbs, and 6g of carbs per medium carrot...I don't see how you could say this meal is 8g of carbohydrates. Your base recipe for this meal posted is with carrots, potatoes etc so people are going to think that is what the nutritional facts and carbs are reflecting . Not the ..."you can use this substitute instead recipe" I think it is misleading. Honestly, maybe list the carb amounts with the substitutions as well as with carrots and potatoes so that people get the reality.
Kim
Mary, I weighed all of my ingredients and entered them into my nutritional calculator. Did you enter the weights? Entering things like "1 medium potato" when it is really 4 oz of waxed potatoes (dived between 8 servings) will give you vastly different numbers. This is a low carb recipe - it's even at acceptable keto levels, and I stand behind it. I also offer ideas for substitutions in the post. Remember that keto is a metabolic state and not a particular food.
It's funny how much criticism I get from this recipe when so many people indulge in cheat days, cheat meals and have no problem eating processed keto treats, chips, and other foods. This is a delicious whole foods low carb recipe. The nutritional information reflects the ingredients in the quantities listed and not the substitutions mentioned in the post. I have not mislead anyone nor would I ever.
I spend weeks testing my own original recipes, tweaking them for best flavor, easiest procedure and best carb counts. I'm honestly offended that you think I would have so little integrity. This is my passion, my livelihood, and I endeavor to share the best tasting recipes low carb/keto recipes I can. -Kim
Mike
If you don’t like the way it’s cooked, it’s simple dont eat it. She at no time said it was carb free, but reduced enough to make the keto list. [...] By the way Kim your recipe is fantastic. And thank you for helping make this miserable diet a little more tolerable.
Kim Hardesty
I'm glad you like the recipe Mike. Have a great week! -Kim
Danielle
AMAZING!! By far my most favorite pot roast I’ve ever made! Hubby loves it!
Karen
Absolutely delicious! I highly recommend this recipe! We made it with grass-fed beef, and I used an inexpensive cabernet savignon for the red-wine. The flavors blended nicely and we thoroughly enjoyed it. We even had enough for left-overs, so I get to have it for lunch tomorrow too!
sue
If I am using a 5 lb roast, would you double the liquids? Anxious to give this a try! Ready for something other than chicken!!!
Kim
Hi Sue. I'm sorry I am late getting to this. I was visiting my folks last week and traveling this past weekend. I don't think I would double the liquids, but make sure to add water if the liquid evaporates during cooking. -Kim
Sandee74
Hi I’ve been keto conscious for about7 months now and I’m surprised that more people don’t portion down hi carb food.Not all foods but I love tacos so I found a tortilla that’s 8n net carbs for 2 well Yum! As long as I’m full and not over my 25 carbs a day- I’m so happy!- I use small potatoes no more than 100g cut them in 4ths and I personally eat one or 2 as they are 5 carbs each - a small carrot is 3 carbs’ not counting the net carbs) - I cut then in 3 so they are now 1 carb each and when it’s in my bowl I slice it to many thin slices and I think I’m eating more! This was great recipe and I hope more people enjoy it- this is the way pot roast was meant to be made a little of this and a little of that!
Bekah
Oh my gosh. I'm the "never comment" type. This is my first roast, and this recipe was beyond perfect. It tastes SO GOOD, I'm dying at work.
I personalized my seasonings, but followed everything else to a T. Thank you for this. My cooking time came out to 4 hours in a Dutch oven.
Bob
Just a question. How is this a low carb recipe. Potatoes and carrots are both high in carbs.
Kim
Hi Bob. It is a low carb recipe as seen by the total and net carbs. I have explained several times in the comments that the amount of potato and carrots equates to a small bite or each person and that it was unfortunate that the largest of the tiny potatoes ended up on the plate. Most recipes for pot roast call for a pound of potatoes and 2-3 large carrots. I believe I also offer options for the potatoes in the post. You can sub with turnip, radish, cauliflower, rutabaga, or celery root. Another source of carbohydrates to be conscious of are onions and garlic. Many low carb and keto bloggers and cooks don't take them into consideration. In any case, this recipe has considerably less carbs than a traditional recipe for pot roast and honestly, I cook for my whole family in mind (my kids are not low carb or keto) and some nights I give the extra bite of carbs to them. -Kim
Elizabeth
Because if you put it all in the carb manager it is what she said it is ... there baby wax potatoes that are not that high in carbs ... everything she wrote down for you is true I check it already ... stop being rhe keto police ..everyone does keto differently. So if you dont like it find another recipe it that simple ...
Colleen Wisniewski
thank you so much this was so good. I didn't eat the potatoes or the carrots but my husband did and we both felt this was the best roast i've ever made. i also used actual cooking wine which had 0 carbs. This is a keeper. Oh and it was done a bit sooner than 3 hours. Thank you so much
Catheh
I just made the pot roast! Simply delicious! I followed the instructions exactly! My poor roast shrunk a little! Ugh! Anyway-I used small potatoes - regular white/red potatoes only about 6 (2 a piece) because I could not find the wax potatoes! Have not clue what those are exactly! My husband really enjoyed it! Next time I make I will use less liquid! No potatoes or carrots! Onions and garlic. And will have cauliflower/broccoli on side! Will have sandwiches tomorrow-rather wraps (using butter lettuce)
Kim
Hi Catheh. I'm glad you liked the recipe. The roast will always shrink - it could have cooked too quickly depending on your oven. I have a large gas oven and I know that my recipes cook faster in my mom's smaller wall oven. You can always reduce the liquid on the stove, which will concentrate the flavors and make it more rich. Some people take some of the veggies and puree them with the liquid to make a thicker gravy. Enjoy your sandwiches. -Kim
Roxenne
This recipe is so delicious!! The roast was packed with flavor and your mashed cauliflower recipe was a perfect substitute for mashed potatoes. Husband didn’t even know the difference. I’ll be making my pot roast this way from now on. Thanks so much for the recipe!!!
Valerie
Tried this today and you’re right, it is very very good. Tasty mix of spices, herbs, veggies and meat. We have liked the chuck roast cut as a favorite for roast for a long time. Thank you for working it all out for us!
Teri
I highly doubt you will see this in time as I have this in the oven right now! I noticed your roast is very flat and two sided whereas mine was three sided and a somewhat tall pyramid shaped, if that makes sense. To fill the Dutch oven with gravy to the “top of the roast” seemed crazy to me as the vegetables would be floating in a red soup. But at the same time, I don’t want a dry roast. Thoughts? It smells wonderful.
Kim
I'm sorry I missed this, Teri. I would have added liquid to half way up the sides of the roast and then added more if needed. I hope your roast turned out alright. -Kim
Terri
This is a wonderful recipe! I added potatoes and carrots since not all 5 in my household eat a low carb diet. However, everyone, including the low carb and keto dieters, all loved this recipe!! It was full of flavor and a nice change from the usual chicken with vegetables. The low-carbers just ate less of the veg ;) this is just one of many recipes of yours that I love. Thank you for sharing!
Kim
Terri, I am thrilled! I do the same thing - have less of the vege or just don't eat certain ones in a dish. That's perfect! Thank you for taking the time to let me know your family enjoys this recipe. I read each comment and it makes my heart full to hear that people enjoy the food they are eating. Have a very nice weekend and happy holidays. -Kim
Becky Louden
I looked for a low carb pot roast and found this. I used a shoulder roast and cooked it in the oven and it turned out so well, the meat fell apart. I love the tomato and red wine gravy, hubby did too.
Kim
I'm so glad Becky. It sounds like a lovely meal. -Kim
Jennifer
I really appreciate the inclusion and explanation of the included carbs. It's my understanding that carbs are included in Keto diets.... through the low carb vegetables and other items. I think it's offensive when someone comments on your website about the inclusion of some of the ingredients listed. You have clearly detailed the reason and experience with other vegetables and starches, thus saving many of us from making the same mistakes. I have to think that the people who have commented negatively, although likely with good intentions, are quick to judge and don't read the information included. Thanks for not being "butt hurt" by negative comments left, and thank you for the effort and information on your website.
Kim
Thanks, Jennifer. I really appreciate your comment. Now to find that awful typo! lol. Have a nice day. -Kim
KetoKitty
you may use some potatoes and carrots in your cooking, but you shouldn't say the recipe is suitable for Atkins or Keto ... they are NOT allowed on either protocol.
Carol
I need to know what is the serving size for one person? Can you be very specific about each food item? Ty!
Carol
Kim
Hi Carol. I shared this recipe 2 years ago and didn't measure the finished product at the end. Since I have a family of four, I divide my dishes by eye. This serves 6 people. I don't know how much more detailed I can be about the ingredients. Can you give me more information? -Kim
Karla
Is the gravy thick? Would I be able to thicken with Xanath Gum for a creamier, thicker gravy?
Kim
Hi Karla. No, this is a highly flavored natural juice gravy, not a thickened gravy. Some people take half of the vegetables and blend them with the juice to thicken. You may use xanthan gum, but I find it deadens flavor a bit. Because this natural gravy has such a nice flavor, my family doesn't mind that it isn't a thickened flour gravy like I used to make. -Kim
Jeni
I thickened the gravy with xantham gum. It was great. I also used rutabaga instead of potatoes. I can't risk a slide off keto with potatoes.
Laura
Will a slow cooker do the same as the pot in the oven?
Kim
No Laura. The oven concentrates flavor while the crock pot dilutes flavor. I suggest that you cook the liquid ingredients down by half before adding them to the crock pot. I have an instant pot, pot roast soup posting later this week! -Kim
Dre
Made this for dinner tonight, used fresh cauliflower instead of potatoes. Didn't have any dry red wine, so I subed it with red wine vinegar. It was really good. Will make again!
Kayle
Absolutely delicious! Thank you for the recipe! My family loved it! Definitely a Keto keeper!
Christina
This dish was amazing! My husband said t was the best dish I have ever made. Thank you this will definitely something that I continue to make for the family.
Kim
I'm so glad you liked the recipe, Christina! -Kim
Diane
i'm looking forward to trying this recipe this weekend. I think what has people confused is the photo (looks yummy) with the quantity of potatoes and carrots in that one serving. At my stage of Keto, my husband will be eating most of the potatoes. I am enjoying your recipes. Thank you VERY much!!
Kim
Yes. It was unfortunate that I put the largest potato in the photo. It was a little larger than a quarter where as the other potatoes were about the size of a nickel. And, in the whole recipe there was about 1 bite of potato per person. Still, a very strict keto person would not add them at all. That's why I suggested alternate ingredients in the post. My kids eat most of the potatoes as kids should have a higher carb allowance. I hope you and your husband enjoy the recipe. Enjoy your day, Diane! -Kim
Mary
This looks wonderful. However, I like to flour and brown before putting into slow cooker. So I add salt, pepper, and garlic powder to almond flour, added the roast and shook well to cover the whole thing. I then brown. In the frying pan drippings, I chop into large pieces an onion. It absorbs the "goodies" from the frying pan which when I put over the roast, adds to the flavor. I then cook for a few hours. But this leaves a sizeable amount of juices in the cooker. I would like suggestions regarding uses so it is not discarded.
Kim
Hi Mary. Crock pot cooking is different than cooking on the stove for sure. Cooking in a pot on the stove releases steam and concentrates flavor while slow cookers make liquid, which waters it down. To be successful in the crockpot, I reduce all liquids called for in a recipe by half before adding it to the slow cooker. That way, the flavor has been concentrated and as the cooker does it magic and makes more liquid, flavor isn't lost. Does this make sense? -Kim
Kim
One more thing I thought of, Mary. You can also remove the excess liquid after cooking and reduce it by half on the stove before serving. The meat will stay hot for a long time and the process doesn't take too long. -Kim
Mae
I am sold on you! Did your Bun less Grilled burgers last night. Served with low carbs tossed salad Filling, tasty and did not miss the bun at all.. Awesome. Just printed out the Low Carb Pot Roast., l
Jennifer
This recipe was great! So much flavor! Thanks for sharing!!
Rita
Jicama makes a great low carb potato substitute! I use it in my pot roast frequently. And it doesn't get mushy and fall apart....
Me
Low carbs? Really ? Potato and carrot ?
Kim
Yes, really! Did you read the post? I offer several subs for the potatoes and even with the tiny amounts of carrot and potato, the recipe is still fits within a ketogenic and low carb life style. I stand behind this recipe. It’s low carb and delicious! -Kim
Bridget
Added this to my list of dinners this week and I'm excited to make it! Is there something I could substitute the wine for? Or can I just omit it? I haven't bought wine because I don't trust myself not to drink the rest of the bottle, and I've only been on Keto for 2 weeks lol!
Overall, this looks amazing and thanks for sharing!
Kim
Oh, the wine is just there to add additional depth of flavor. You can leave it out, Bridget. Congratulations on your two weeks! Enjoy the recipe. -Kim
Hilary
This looks amazing. Love the gravy with tomato paste. As I'm making a keto slaw today that calls for a bit of tomato paste, this will be perfect for tomorrow! I'll be cooking in a pressure cooker (no oven as I'm in an extended stay). Looking very forward to trying this! And you are amazingly patient about the low carb comments. Kudos to you!
Kim
Hilary, I love how you brought your pressure cooker to an extended stay. You are amazing. I have never made this in a pressure cooker but for a crock pot, I reduce the cooking liquid by half before adding it to the crock pot. I hope you enjoy the recipe. Thank you for the nice compliments. Enjoy your weekend. -Kim
cj
I've made this twice. My husband loves it!
Kim
I'm so glad to hear it CJ. I love this recipe, too. Thanks for taking the time to leave a comment letting me know. Have a great day. -Kim
Nano
How is this a low carb meal with potatoes and carrots in it? Why bother making cauli-mash if you've already added starchy veggies in it? Hmmmm
Kim
Hi, Nano. This is absolutely a low carb recipe. It's even a ketogenic recipe. Did you read the post? Have you ever done Atkins? Have you read my article Low Carb for beginners?
The term Low Carb is very ambiguous and can mean many things to many people. Dr. Atkins' plan had a strict two week Induction period which eliminated many trigger foods. After the two weeks, foods were systematically added back into the diet as carbs were also increased. This was the second phase. And people found their trigger foods and exactly how many carbs they could consume and still lose.
Next, after almost at goal weight people were to add more carbs to find the level of carbs their body needed to sustain and not gain or lose. Almost all foods can be added back in maintenance as long as they do not trigger cravings and that they are eaten in a healthful way.
I think you will agree that 1 smallish carrot divided between 8 people results in a very small portion. Likewise, a 1/4 pound of potato split 8 ways results in about one bite. In the context of a whole meal or even in a whole days worth of eating, that's a really small amount. And, since we eat with our eyes, a beautiful pot roast that has a little color and a bite of the familiar is absolutely on plan and may help people stay on plan.
I've read countless books and articles about low carb and ketogenic diets over the last 8 years or so. I even lead my 50k Facebook followers through Induction in January and shared my meals and macros with them during that time. Several people lost 8-10 pounds at that time with my help and guidance.
If you don't want to add the small amount of carrot or potato to the recipe then leave them out. But, this recipe is absolutely low carb!
Thank you for your questions. I hope my answer has helped. For more information I suggest reading Dr. Atkins New Diet Revolution or any of his original books. His books are well written and very informative including all of the steps to make low carb a sustainable lifestyle. -Kim
Alrx
What would be the slow cooker time/temp?
Kim
The recipe for cooking the pot roast in the slow cooker is different. Reduce the liquid on the stove by half and cook the pot roast on low until cooked 8-10 hours. -Kim
Maggie
Just made this for my dinner this week; froze most of the portions to eat for later. I totally agree with small amounts of high carb ingredients — currently on a low carb (90g)/high protein (100g) diet. I can't imagine just going cold turkey on carbs! Thank you for this recipe! It was super easy to follow and not too expensive for a broke college student like me. :)
Kim
I hope you enjoy the recipe this week, Maggie. -Kim
Judy
Finally a recipe that is home cooked with home style that the whole family loves without changing a thing!
Kim
Judy! Thanks for that. I have received so many negative remarks on this recipe because it has a little carrot and potato in the recipe - not because any of those criticizing tried the recipe. My cousin's wife tried the recipe and liked it. She is a pastry chef and enjoys good food. I hope you enjoy it, too. I appreciate your kind comment. You make my weekend! Enjoy. -Kim
Leslie Brooks
Quick question before I try to make this as it looks delicious. Can regular onions, sliced or cut into chunks, be substituted for the pearl onions? I do not think the store where I buy my groceries sells pearl onions. Thanks so much. It is great finding a site with so many low carb dishes.
Kim
Absolutely, Leslie. Thanks for the nice compliment. Kim
Julie
I thought you couldn't eat carrots and potatoes while doing low carb. They tell you don't eat eat anything below the ground.
Kim
Hi Julia. While a ketogenic diet is strict about how many grams of fat, protein and carbohydrates are eaten and total carbs are kept under 50 grams a day, the term "low carb" is very ambiguous. The Induction phase of Atkins is ketogenic and also an elimination diet - meaning it eliminates most starchy and augury foods that may cause cravings. The second phase of Atkins has one add back carbs and many of those foods. Some people still lose weight at 100 total carbs a day and some even more. I must keep my net carbs at 20-25 grams to lose weight, but I have added back most foods. This recipe basically gives each person a bite of potato and a few tiny pieces of carrot. I make pot roast 1-3 times a year so this is not a big deal for me personally. The onion in the recipe has as many carbs as the tiny potatoes or the carrot. As a rule, I don't eat much that grows below the ground, but since the amount is small and infrequently eaten, I make room in my diet to enjoy these things if a tiny amount enhances a dish. As you can see, the net carbs of the dish are in line with both low carb and ketogenic diets. Have a nice day. -Kim
Debbie
That looks really good! I agree with you, if you want to throw in a carrot & a couple of potatoes, by all means, do it. The "carb police" I've encountered on some sites will have their say, no matter what. But I wanted to say, that the first (and only!) roast I made in the crockpost a few weeks back, I added a 1# bag of large radishes & my husband & I both thought they looked and tasted just like small red potatoes. We were amazed! Love all your recipes & hard work!
Kim
Aww. Thanks Debbie. My radishes sogged out. :( Perhaps I should have added them at the last hour of cooking? I'll try that next time. I appreciate the suggestion. :) -Kim
Debbie
My husband is amazed at some of the low carb foods-the radishes being one of them. But it works-my blood work came back so good, I'm no longer pre-diabetic & my doc told me to stop taking the statin I've been on for several years. At 65 (in less than a week!) I really can't see me going back to the old WOE. No need to when you keep providing such yumny recipes! Happy Holidays to you & your family!
Kim
Deb, I'm so happy your health is improving an at 65, it shows that anyone at any age can do it. Thanks again for taking the time for commenting. You enjoy your holidays, too. Take care. -Kim
Bill
Wow that looks amazing! I'm trying to stay very low carb do I would have to avoid the potatoes and the carrots. I think I would still put them in and cook with them to get the flavor from them though.
Kim
Thanks, Bill. The amounts of vegetable are really minimal, but everyone has to do what they think is best. I hope you like the recipe. Enjoy your week. -Kim
Diane
I have been searching for someone who knows how to cook healthy low carb. Grateful I found you.
Kim
What a nice thing to say, Diane. Thank you! - Kim
Hope
I didn't think I could have taters and carrots but 6 carbs per serving is real good so I'll be making this for sure !
Kim
Hi Hope. If you think about it, it's 1 quarter of a 1 pound potato split between 6-8 people. Same thing with the carrot. The amount you get of each is very small. If you have diabetes, test afterwards and see if it affects you. If you are just too leery maybe throw in a bunch of whole radishes the last hour of cooking. I hope you enjoy the recipe. -Kim
Rachel
This looks really good right now!
Kim
Thanks, Rachel! -Kim
Carolsue
This stew looks so yummy -- I love beef stew recipes
Kim
Thank you, Carolsue! -Kim
Taryn
That pot roast looks amazing! My husband loves stick-to-the-ribs types of meals like this one!
Kim
Thank you Taryn. It was a meal loved my the whole family and perfect for cooler weather. Enjoy your week. -Kim
Georgina
Yes I can imagine this is perfect with cauli mash!
Kim
It was a dream, thanks Georgina. Have a great week. -Kim
STACEY
I also use higher carb ingredients in small amounts as well. It can really keep your low carb diet more doable. I have to say that this is the prettiest photo of pot roast I have ever seen! Looks completely glorious.
Kim
Hi Stacey. Yes, being able to work the plan so you can continue is important. Thank you for the nice compliment. Have a wonderful week. -Kim
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Your pot roast looks absolutely perfect! I love making these because the oven really does do most of the work freeing myself for other things!
Kim
Thank you, Maya. Dinner couldn't get simpler than pot roast. Have a wonderful rest of the weekend. -Kim
Adina
Oh, that looks so amazing, I love such a roast! I have to find out what a chuck roast is in German, so I can buy the right thing. :)
Kim
Thank you for the compliment, Adina. I'm sure you have similar roast recipes in Europe and they are all nourishing and amazing. I love visiting you site to see what delicious food you are making. Have a nice weekend. -Kim
Amy Hubbard
Kim, I don't have a Dutch oven. What could I use instead?
Kim
If you don't have a lidded pot or roaster big enough then you can try do cook it in the crock pot. Season and brown the meat then put it in the crock pot. Then, reduce the liquid for the recipe by half. I would add the vegetables at the last hour or so of cooking, so they aren't mushy. -Kim
Kim
By "reduce the liquid for the recipe by half" I mean to cook it in a small pot until it is reduced by half and then add it to the crockpot with the roast.